Endurance vs. Fortegra: Which Auto Warranty Provider Offers Better Coverage?
Both Endurance and Fortegra offer extended auto warranty coverage, but they differ significantly in their approach and services. Here's a detailed comparison:
Coverage Options
Endurance:
- Direct provider with 7 customizable plans
- Supreme Plan (most comprehensive)
- Supreme for Highline Vehicles (luxury cars)
- Superior Plan (crucial components)
- Select Premier (high-mileage vehicles)
- Secure Plus (basic components)
- Secure Plan (powertrain coverage)
- Advantage Plan (includes maintenance)
Fortegra:
- Dealer-based coverage
- No specific pre-made plans
- Offers mechanical, pre-pay maintenance, lifetime warranty
- Coverage varies by dealership
Fortegra car warranty plans overview
Customer Service Experience
Endurance:
- High Trustpilot rating with 9,000+ reviews
- A- BBB rating
- Direct claims handling
- Praised for helpful customer service
Fortegra:
- Low Trustpilot rating
- Multiple complaints about denied claims
- Indirect service through dealers
- Inconsistent customer experience
Claims Process
Endurance:
- Simple direct process
- Use any certified repair shop
- No upfront payment needed
- In-house claims handling
Fortegra:
- More complex process
- Dealer-preferred repairs
- May require upfront payment
- Reimbursement-based system
Additional Benefits
Endurance:
- 24/7 roadside assistance
- Rental car coverage
- Travel interruption coverage
- Elite Benefits program available
- Coverage for specialty vehicles
Fortegra:
- Optional add-ons available
- Tire protection
- Key protection
- Roadside assistance
- GAP coverage
- Pricing varies by dealer
Bottom Line: Endurance offers more transparent, comprehensive coverage with better customer service and a simpler claims process, while Fortegra provides dealer-based coverage with varying terms and less consistent customer experience.
Related Articles
Reduce Subaru Maintenance Costs with an Auto Protection Plan
