When choosing between Endurance and ASE Protection Warranty for extended vehicle coverage, there are several key differences to consider:

Coverage Options

Endurance:

• 7 customizable plans including Supreme, Superior, Select Premier, Secure Plus, Secure, and Advantage
• Covers high-mileage, luxury, and commercial-use vehicles
• Offers mechanical breakdown insurance in California
• 30-day money-back guarantee
• Includes maintenance coverage in select plans

ASE Protection Warranty:

• 3 fixed plans: Blue Shield, Blue Shield PLUS, and Total Blue Shield
• Basic to comprehensive coverage options
• More limited vehicle eligibility

Customer Service & Reviews

Endurance:

• High Trustpilot rating with 9,000+ reviews
• A- BBB rating
• Award-winning customer service team
• Quick claim processing

ASE Protection Warranty:

• 1.8/5 Trustpilot rating
• F rating from BBB
• Limited customer service responsiveness
• Multiple complaints about payment processing

Claims Process

Endurance:

• Simple repair shop process
• Direct shop-to-provider communication
• 24/7 mobile app access
• Customer only pays deductible

ASE Protection Warranty:

• Requires customer mediation between shop and provider
• More complicated claims process
• Limited digital access

Additional Benefits

Endurance:

• 24/7 roadside assistance
• Rental car coverage
• Trip interruption coverage
• Elite Benefits package including tire repair/replacement and key fob replacement
• $1,000 total loss protection

ASE Protection Warranty:

• Courtesy towing only
• No additional perks or benefits

Final Verdict: Endurance offers more comprehensive coverage options, better customer service, and additional benefits compared to ASE Protection Warranty. While potentially more expensive, Endurance provides superior value and peace of mind for vehicle protection.

Related Articles

Previous Articles